by Abigail Wyse
I went to a comedy club once and made the mistake of sitting in the front row. I served as a muse of sorts to the first comedian, whose entire act more or less centered around poking fun of me. Though the crowd roared, I didn’t find the show all that amusing and soon after renounced live comedy as something that just wasn’t for me.
Then I learned about Kristen Schaal and alternative comedy.
I had been a victim of traditional stand-up comedy, which relies on punch line based jokes and loves to use stereotypes to make fun of others. Making a conscious break from the mainstream comedic style of the time period, alternative comedy uses other elements to draw the laughter out of the audience. For the most part, alternative comedy is comprised of intelligent commentary and jokes, so it requires some level of intellectual participation from the viewer. Rather than making fun of others, alternative comedians prefer to often look inward and laugh at themselves and the daily occurrences of their lives. Other characteristics of alternative comedy include political satire, breaking social taboos and barriers, especially in terms of language, improvisation, personal narrative and use of characters. Alternative comedy assumes a well-informed audience, as many alternative comedians are not only driven to entertain but to send a message as well.
Alternative comedy originated in the United Kingdom in the late 1970’s and was influenced by both British nonsense writings of the Victorian period and the Satire Boom of the 1950s and 60s. Developed during a period of serious political division in Britain, this style truly is a product of its time and environment. Alternative comedy made its debut in America on the left coast in Los Angeles. It all began when performance artist-turned-comedian Beth Lapides began putting on comedy shows at less likely venues. She and her fellow soon-to-be alternative comedians dubbed their show “Un-Cabaret” for their untraditional humor and approach to live comedy that was based in storytelling and stream-of-consciousness rants. Today, alternative comedy is experiencing a revival in many places such as Toronto, Chicago and Seattle.
On the other side of the country, Kristin Schaal hosted a weekly variety show called “Hot Tub” in New York, where the East Village serves as the primary hub for alternative comedy acts. The Longmont, Colorado native moved to New York after graduating from Northwestern University to pursue a career in comedy. Schaal got her first break in 2005 when her show “Hot Tub” was voted “Best Variety Show of 2005” by Time Out New York’s reader poll and she was also included in New York Magazine’s list of “The Ten Funniest New Yorkers You’ve Never Heard Of.” She has quickly become a staple in the East Village alternative comedy scene, which features shows that offer more character-based and surreal humor. She is also a founding member of “The Striking Viking Story Pirates”, which adapts stories by children into sketches and songs.
Among the various highlights of Schaal’s career is her performance at the Royal Albert Hall in London at The Secret Policeman’s Ball to aid Amnesty International. She has won many awards for her live comedy, including “Best Female Stand-Up Comedian” at the 2007 ECNY Awards and the Barry Award for her show “Kristen Schaal as You Have Probably Never Seen her Before” at the 2008 Melbourne International Comedy Festival. Schaal has also appeared on television, most notably for her role as the stalker-fan Mel, on HBO’s Flight of the Concords, as well as on The Daily Show, where she often serves as the show’s “Senior Women’s Issues Correspondent.”
Schaal will bring her brand of alternative comedy to The Center for the Arts on September 18, 2009.